Sunday, January 22, 2017

Generation Edge

Whenever I read anything about generations and their differences, I find myself both fascinated and annoyed. Understanding how the technology and culture of a particular time influences people is very interesting to me. However, I find the broad and general descriptions of a group of people based only on when they were born to be very limiting and short sighted. I see the value in trying to understand our students and how they world they grown up in influences their learning styles, however not all students will fit all the prescribed characteristics of the millennial or edge generations.

Despite my hesitations at applying generalizations to students, I do notice some of my students exhibiting the characteristics that researchers have attributed to the edge generation. In Sarah Fudin’s article, she mentions that one of the most striking differences between the edge generation and previous generations is their ability to multitask. When I first began working in high schools three years ago, this was something I immediately noticed. I observe students working on school work, listening to music, responding to text messages, and chatting with friends (in class) all the at same time. At first, I thought this was impossible and would be detrimental to their work. However, many students do seem able to multitask and still be successful. This is something that I personally cannot do. When I am reading or writing, I need to focus on the task at hand. I find music and my phone to be distractions, however, most of my students have had a phone (or ipad or similar device) essentially since birth. They seem to have integrated the use of this technology into everything they do.

Another characteristic of the edge student that is mentioned in Amy Lynch’s article is their desire for more privacy online than the previous millennial generation. Most of my students seems to use more one-on-one forms of social media such as SnapChat or Instagram Stories. Many of them do not have a Facebook at all (or if they do it is seldom used). Instead of broadcasting their actions and whereabouts to the world, they seem to be happier using social media to communicate one on one with smaller groups of friends. This also fits in with the Southern Connecticut State University article which states :

“GenEdgers may be able to create authentic, meaningful relationships with people via Skype and other technological devices in which people can see each other, even though they may be physically a long distance away from each other.

My students are obsessed with taking pictures, SnapChat, and FaceTime. They stay in contact and form relationships through screens. This is totally normal to them, since as I previously stated, this technology has been in use for their entire lives. My students actually asked me last semester if I would create a SnapChat account for the class where I could post homework assignment reminders into the story.

Finally, in the Research Live article, the authors mention that Gen Edgers are much less likely to be influenced by brands. I can also see some truth in that. I myself am a millennial, and when I was in high school brands were all that mattered in clothing, accessories, cars, media etc. However, my students today seem much less interested and influenced by brands. They are more skeptical about the intentions of companies. I think it will be very interesting to see how brands adapt their marketing strategies over the next decade in order to reach a more skeptical and private consumer.

7 comments:

  1. I, too, am surprised at the ability of students to multitask. As a classroom teacher and a one-task-at-a-time baby boomer it would appear to be counterproductive. However, you as well as the author, solidified the fact that students, GenEdgers and Millennials, have that innate ability to accomplish multiple tasks with no problem. With that being said, I appreciate all of the articles' fine tuned descriptions on what to expect from students in the 21st century. As educators, we enter the classroom with a set of expectations based on what worked for us in previous years only to be met with challenges that we must be willing to overcome in order to have a successful school year.
    Also, as a baby boomer, the terminology has changed. Behaviors and language that was unfamiliar to adults fell into the category of "generation gap". Currently, the access of literature to explain the generational differences is abundant. So what does that mean? No one has an excuse for not understanding what is going on with all age groups.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The issue I want to bring to this discussion is the concept of multitasking and having 'no problem' or 'doing it well.' Research has shown this to be a myth. It gives the appearance they can do it well, but that implies that they would perform 5 tasks in isolation JUST AS WELL as 5 tasks done 'simultaneously' (i.e., bouncing back and forth between them). Further, if they do perform better multitasking, why is student academic performance supposedly stagnant or falling?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is a very valid question, and I'm not sure I know the answer to it. However, I think it would be very difficult to convince my students that they shouldn't/can't multitask. It seems like we need to find someway to work with the students who are inevitably going to be doing multiple other things while they do schoolwork.

      Delete
    2. As I mentioned on someone else's blog, the experiment is rather easy to replicate (give them two tasks to do in isolation, then give two similar tasks, and have them alternate on 2 minute intervals, or interrupt one with the other every 2 minutes).

      Delete
  3. I actually never thought of snapchat being a way to remind students of assignments and other things in the class. I’m curious if you tried it and whether it was successful or not?

    This generation is much more connected to each other than even we as millennials were. Yes, we had texting, but it wasn’t a keyboard and the constant clicking for “hi how r u” is not the same thing as proper sentences, pictures and live video that are used today. I cringe anytime I have to use facetime, while students happily use it daily. There was one app, “House Party,” that was circulating a month or two ago that allowed multiple people to connect to a facetime call at once, and that was popular for a time.

    Because students aren’t getting the same personal, face-to-face connections as previous generations, how does this change the way the we interact with the world? We see hurtful comments online all time, mainly because the majority of the time nobody has to face any consequences. The anonymity allows people to hurt others without seeing the effect. Does this mean we’ll lose compassion soon? Or we can look at it from the prospect of everyone is connected. I’m pretty sure twitter is still commonly used by edgers, and people across the world aren’t far from us online. It’s a fine line whether technology hurts or promotes our empathy- a lot it obviously being stemming from how a person is raised and how the people around them acts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did not use snapchat for a couple of reasons. First, if I added them on snapchat, even as a class only account, I would be able to see their snapchat stories, and I'm not comfortable with that. Secondly, this was during my student teaching experience, and our field instructors made it very clear we should not be communicating with students on social media beyond what their actual classroom teacher uses (she used Schoology). I think ultimately creating a class snapchat would just open the door to a lot of potential problems.

      I think the anonymity of some of the app teenagers use is very concerning. I remember when YikYak was a popular a couple of years ago. It is basically like a location based completely anonymous twitter. It caused a lot of problems- students could post nasty things about one another with no consequences (because there was no way to tell who posted it). I think we really need to focus on teaching kids internet ethics at a very young age. They need to understand that what is said online can have effects in real life.

      Delete
    2. I would check out remind.com. They sign up with their cell number (which you never see), and you send out reminders via the site. Good for parents, too. (Because, trust me, they're not going to your class website as often as you'd like).

      Delete